When your strengths aren’t always helpful
A dial on a blue background. Around the dial are 5 colours from green to red. The arrow on the dial is pointing between amber and red

Posted on Sep 2, 2026

We all have strengths

 

We spend a lot of time thinking about our strengths as leaders. We identify what we’re good at, build on it and find ways to use those qualities effectively. But strengths aren’t helpful in every situation.  

Sometimes, particularly when we’re under pressure, they can become a little too much of a good thing. The leader who is naturally decisive can start making decisions before others have had a chance to contribute. Someone who cares deeply about their team can begin taking responsibility for everyone else’s problems. High standards can become perfectionism. Resilience can become pushing through when stopping would be wiser. The strength is still there. It’s simply being overused. 

Look underneath 

When we notice a behaviour we don’t like in ourselves, our instinct can be to try to stop it. But what if we got curious instead?  

There is often a positive intention sitting underneath behaviour that has become unhelpful. The person struggling to delegate wants to make sure things are done well. The leader who keeps stepping in to solve problems wants to support their team. The person who keeps pushing through cares deeply about getting the job done. 

Looking underneath the behaviour doesn’t mean excusing it. It means understanding it. And understanding gives us more options. 

What are we afraid of? 

Sometimes there is another layer underneath all of this: fear. 

When we’re under pressure, our response isn’t always about what is happening in the moment. It can be about what we’re afraid might happen next. We might become overly controlling because we’re afraid something will go wrong. Take on too much because we’re afraid of letting someone down. Avoid a difficult conversation because we’re afraid of damaging a relationship. Keep searching for another solution because we’re afraid we haven’t found the right one. 

The behaviour makes more sense when we understand what it’s trying to protect us from. That doesn’t make the behaviour helpful, but it can make it easier to understand. And understanding creates the possibility of choice and opens the door to more self-compassion. 

Pressure changes things 

We’re particularly likely to overuse our strengths when we’re tired, stressed, uncertain or facing a difficult situation. When pressure rises, we tend to reach for what we know. We rely more heavily on familiar ways of responding, even when they’re no longer serving us particularly well. 

This is why we might find ourselves behaving differently during a particularly challenging week than we would when we have more space, energy and perspective. It’s not that the strength has suddenly become a problem. The circumstances have changed, and our response may need to change with them. 

Get curious 

Instead of seeing the things we struggle with as flaws to fix, we can become curious about what sits underneath them. We might notice that the quality we value most in ourselves is sometimes the very quality that gets us into difficulty. 

That doesn’t mean we need to change who we are. It means we can become more aware of when we’re leaning too heavily on a particular strength and more intentional about how we respond. Over the next few weeks, notice what happens to your own strengths when the pressure rises. You might be surprised by what you discover. 

Related posts 

What are you taking with you into next school year?

What are you taking with you into next school year?

As the school year draws to a close, there is often a pull towards reinvention. September can start to feel like a blank page where everything will finally fall into place, where organisation improves, leadership becomes easier or where a more refined version of ourselves emerges. It is an appealing idea, particularly after a demanding year. 

School leadership when everything is changing

School leadership when everything is changing

There are moments in school leadership when it can feel like everything is shifting at the same time. Not just in one area, but across different parts of the system all at once. That’s certainly how a lot of my clients are feeling at the moment, with new expectations, shifting guidance, and ongoing demands continuing regardless of what else is changing around them. 

September; new year, old patterns

September; new year, old patterns

There’s a point in the year when many school leaders start to think, “I’ll deal with that in September.” I know because I’ve thought it myself and it makes sense on the surface. September feels like a natural reset point, a new academic year and a chance to start differently. But in reality, it rarely offers what we imagine it will.

Comments

0 Comments